Here are the occasional reflections of a joyful traveller along the strange pathways of fantasy and adventure. All my reviews are independent and unsolicited. I read many books that I don’t feel sufficiently enthusiastic about to review at all. Rather, this blog is intended as a celebration of the more interesting books I stumble across on my meandering reading journey, and of the important, life-affirming experiences they offer. It is but a very small thank you for the wonderful gifts their writers give.

Sunday, 4 June 2017

The Night Spinner by Abi Elphinstone

 

Imagination and originality

Sometimes truly original and imaginative fantasies seems easier to find for teenagers (and even 'tweenagers') than for children. Fantasy writing for 7-11s too often falls into somewhat tired cliché* and, even though young readers often enjoy this well enough, they still deserve writing that is fresh and vibrant. Fortunately, then, there seems to have been a quite a spate of new and exciting children's fantasy recently. For example, Jennifer Bell in The Uncommoners, has created a hugely imaginative sub-London of magical objects and their 'traders' which is as exciting as it is entertaining. A writer who can conjure a world where a toilet brush convincingly presents a menacing threat, is clearly very clever, and very original. Peter Bunzl's Cogheart is also innovative and engaging. He brings a version of steam-punk fantasy to a younger readership and his 'clockwork' Victorian adventure ticks along thrillingly. Its sequel is newly out,  and The Uncimmoners has one due very soon,  so I am eager to write about both in more detail as soon as I have caught up with their latest incarnations. 

A fine trilogy completed 

Meanwhile we now have the final book of Abi Elphinstone's trilogy (started in The Dream Snatcher) - and very welcome it is too. I rated the first two books very highly (see my post from March '16. ) and this conclusion fully supports my view that the series is an outstanding 'entry level' to magic fiction for younger readers.  The Night Spinner expands even further  the world of the previous instalments, and, indeed, the wonderful sense of adventure at which this author excels. It also has the advantage of one of the strongest girl protagonists around, supported by loyal friends both male and animal, a delightful combination that makes the books appealing and accessible to a wide readership. Its evil threat is spine-tinglingly sinister, without ever quite descending into the disturbingly macabre, and its climaxes are truly exciting. 

The importance of adventure 

Adventure and imagination are two companions which can make an enormous potential contribution to child development. In fact I would call them essential components of truly healthy growth. Sadly many contemporary children seem to have too little adventure in their lives. Overprotectivenes and so-called 'health and safety' have tended to suffocate it, as has the stranglehold of the mobile phone. Children don't need literally to canoe the Amazon to experience adventure. Our own children benefitted considerably from roaming the fields, woods and farm behind our Lancashire home. They thrived, despite all too often arriving back at teatime stinking of cow muck. So did we grow through our day-long bike expeditions to the 'Yellow Hills' outside industrial Blackburn; our parents through their childhood marauding down back alleys and scavenging on the bomb sires. Enormously valuable though the learning of a musical instrument may prove, being chauffeured from one after-school class or club to the next is no substitute for adventure. And actual adventure is the best. But the vicarious adventure to be found in books is an excellent supplement, and, for those children denied real adventure by our contemporary society, far, far better than nothing. Abi Elphinstone is an adventurer herself and shares the spirit and experience of adventure better than almost any other contemporary children's writer. All power to her and her adventurous Moll. 

'Run with wild horses. Stand tall on the highest mountains. Swim beneath thundering waterfalls.'

Our children can - and perhaps one day they will. 

 

Note:
* I must say I have become very jaded (and indeed put off) by the many book titles which blatantly mimick the Harry Potter formula. You know 'Somebody Somebody and the Something of Something.'; 'Tommy Cup and the Saucer of Gloom' and the like. They may sell books, but I can think of few such copycat titles that belong to outstanding works in their own right.  

Wednesday, 3 May 2017

The Forever Court by Dave Rudden



 

The sequel arrives

Here is a book for rather older children, or perhaps particularly for those caught on the awkward cusp between late childhood and young adulthood. The author calls it a 'dark, strange, sad book' and he is not wrong. It is a challenging read but it is also a breathtakingly wonderful one. 

Dave Rudden's opening book in the Knights of the Borrowed Dark series was Children's Book of the Year in the 2016 Irish Book Awards - and deservedly so. It was a truly remarkable start to his new sequence. (See my post from May '16.) In fact it should have won stacks of other awards too, and could well have done so were it not for something of a prejudice, I fear, against magic fantasy as a genre, and in favour of novels about 'real life issues'. Fear not.  Dave Rudden's time will come, I am sure, with this second Knights'book only adding to his reputation. It extends far beyond and above the first. Book 2 to Book 1 is as moth to caterpillar. 

Depths soon emerge

Initially, the opening title seemed to sit very firmly in the 'orphan-discovers-he-has-magical-talents-and-is-taken-off-to-fight-unimaginable-evil-and-ends-up-saving-the-world' sort of book.  Superficially it is. However it soon develops multiple levels of depth, huge originality and downright quality by the shedload. 

The Forever Court also starts with a very genre-typical 'boy-hero-and-mates-beat-up-gruesome-monster' episode. (Even here, though, Dave Rudden manages to get in a very strong positive image of his young hero as a reader, which is more than a bonus.) However, this simplistic format doesn't hold sway for very long. The first book came to a cataclysmic conclusion with shocking deaths and a staggering encounter between protagonist, Denizen and, well, someone else. (No spoilers, or at least not big ones.) There were other shocking discoveries about  his own family history, too.

A real boy in a fantasy world

It doesn't take long for the fallout from all of these to impact dramatically on the story of Book 2. This is no two-dimensional comic book tale. It is indeed a story of the fight to the death between the grotesquely monstrous, other-worldly 'Tenebrous' and the 'Knights' whose only raison d'etre is to destroy them. But is is also very much the story af a thirteen-year-old boy. Denizen's insides now churn with anger about the way life, and his parents, have treated him. This same anger is echoed in the powers of terrible magic fire that he has been given. They too burn inside him and take all his efforts to contain. Either or both could easily consume him.  More is added to his emotional turmoil when he is plunged into the trauma a of a first love - with possibly the most unsuitable 'girl' imaginable. Or maybe not even that. He is lost, confused, every inch the young teenager. He is a true denizen of humanity, a boy of sorrows and aquainted with frowns; he has so many ways of furrowing his brow that he has them all mentally catalogued, numbered and classified. 

However Denizen is sensitive and intelligent too. He thinks, he questions, and, through him, the book delves deeply into the moral ambivalences, the ambiguities that lurk between the extremes of good and evil on which his new world is predicated. He can see that, 'Evil isn't a cliff you fall from, it's a staircase you climb.' He is no cardboard hero, nor his author any slouch at turning a phrase. 

Most telling of all, perhaps, is the constant interpolation of this 'normal' thirteen-year-old into the context of superheroism in which he finds himself. The back cover blurb of this edition pulls the wonderful quote: 'The last time Denizen had seen Mercy, he'd had to save the world. He really hoped he wasn't going to have to save it again.' In itself,  this entertainingly points the incongruity between heroic deeds and a rather cynical teenager. However, I liked even better the passage which immediately follows. It continues, 'Afterwards, Denizen and Simon got chips. It was a little anticlimactic,' and concludes, 'Maybe that was why Knights were continually on edge - you never knew whether the next five minutes would contain soul-crushing horror or chips with garlic sauce.' Delicious. The writing and the chips. 

Excitement aplenty

Yet all of this sits within a rich, enthralling plot about a war, laced with an outside chance of peace. The high-adrenaline plot twists and turns like the passages of a labyrinth. And there is certainly a monster at its centre. But the exact nature of the beast is far less clear. Where does all the belligerence, all the killing, come from? Who is to be trusted? 'Hatred and fear build like rust,' and they seem to be corroding Denizen's world away.  Can his being a Kight, actually make things better, or is the very act of protecting the world destroying it? He has already saved the world once . . .

A further deep, rich seam is added to this new phase of the story by what seems, for much of the book, to be an unconnected  sub-plot. Strange, dark, and enigmatic, it adds an enthralling new array of images. Here are a new set of characters, an isolated cult of humans who believe themselves the chosen ones of their 'Redemptress', a disturbing figure of wires housed in the corpse of a castle . They are preparing themselves for a 'war to come' with only their gargantuan belief in themselves, the favoured ones, to pit against all comers. All who are not  'us' are 'them'; those who do not believe,  those who do not belong. The 'family' have been preparing themselves for generations. Keeping the faith. Doing Her will. They  are Croits, badged with the crow and the claw. And their fanaticism resonates so strongly with that in our own world that it is terrifying. Deeply disturbing. 

Amongst the Croits is a boy, Uriel, and his twin sister. He trains to fight, he prepares for war, like all the Croits. He builds his hate for 'them', his desperation to kill any, or preferably all.  His heritage is to serve Her. But, like Denizen, he thinks too. He questions. And it will be his salvation. Or his downfall. 
 
When the two strands of story do come together they do so with inevitable violence. Their final confluence bring startling revelations,  but little resolution. New understanding , but, with it. new conflict. Now there are two boys, Denizen and Uriel, alike and different, both seeking the source that corrupts their world, both hoping desperately to find, to save what they love. But each is lost in the labyrinth. Is it the same maze? Are their different paths leading them towards the same monster?

This author knows exactly how and when to rack up the tension, even when you think all is already stretched to breaking point. And, through it all, his masterly and original use of language galvanises the reader's imagination like a current of electricity. Sometimes it shocks, sometimes it tingles. He can turn a phrase, conjure an image, bring characters and action into vivid focus better than almost any writer of children's fiction I know. Constantly the flux of his linguistic power reacts against your own imagination, coats it and strengthens it. No headset is necessary for a virtual reality to boot itself inside your mind. You see every scene, think every thought, feel every fear. You churn with all the anger and all the love of a hugely confused thirteen-year old. You live every visceral moment of gripping action. The world Dave Rudden has created is all around you; outside you, and within. It is your world now. You will always have to live with the image of the truly terrifying flock of crows that form the body of malevolent Malebranche. On you inward eye is forever engraved the picture of Denizen and the awesome Mercy in an embassy garden in Dublin where they almost . . . Perhaps you will hear them too. 'And deafening came the sound of wings.' ; 'She laughed again, a sound like raindrops, if raindrops knew how to dance.' (A great book is so eminently quotable.)

A classic in the making

This is fiction, in all its power and potency. See.  Hear. Think. Feel. Endure. Remember. Know. 

At the close of this second book, the small consolations offered come nowhere close to offsetting much impending dread. The narrative of Knights of the Borrowed Dark is growing into something monumental. It seems to be careering towards Apocalypse. But will there be redemption? Like The Lord of the Rings, it treats of the possibility of saving everything and the risk of losing everything. It places the small and vulnerable at the heart of all that is huge and terrible   It  celebrates goodness and castigates evil. Unlike that illustrious predecessor, however, it simultaneously questions the nature of each, and even the distinction between them. Just as Tolkien' s world echoed that of WWII and its aftermath, so this one somehow resonates profoundly with our own times. Are Denizen and Uriel true heros or just lost and confused boys? 

Unless he messes up on Part 3, which seems unlikely, it begins to look like Dave Rudden has used the children's/YA genre to craft one of the great works of fantasy literature. And good on him for that. 

Those who demean fantasy fiction, considering it inferior to books about 'real life' and 'real issues' are missing out. Unkindly, one might say it is their loss. However when they are parents or teachers, or those who influence them, it can mean that it is young people who ultimately miss out and that is saddening and infuriating in equal measure. This book is the epitome of what the very best fantasy can offer. It is a challenging read, both intellectually and emotionally. It is thought provoking about big issues which profoundly affect our lives and our world. It is written in language that is surprising, exciting and enriching. And all of this is in the context of a narrative that is as compulsively page-turning as it is disturbing. It is indeed a dark, strange, sad book. 

'What could we become in the dark but monsters?'

Dave Rudden's writing is the best thing since . . . well . . . since chips with garlic sauce. 

 

Heads up USA. This stunner of a book is due out with you August '17. 


Wednesday, 26 April 2017

Exciting new edition of The Wee Free Men

 
To mark 'Terry Pratchett Day' (the author's anniversary, on April 28th) , Penguin (Corgi) are publishing a new edition of this little masterpiece with a fresh, child-friendly cover. To accompany it, they have also produced a free 'virtually live' webcast for schools. (puffinvirtuallylive.co.uk)

I hope this initiative will help to introduce a new generation of children (and  their teachers) to this first book in the Tiffany Aching series. These are amongst the few Discworld titles written especially for a younger audience and the sequence is undoubtedly one of the real gems of 21st century children's fantasy. (See my posts from June '14 and Sept '15.)

This first book is tremendous fun, accessible and engrossing. Trainee witch,Tiffany, is a strong, likeable protagonist and shares her story with the  Nac Mac Feegles, a clan of tiny but belligerent warriors who must rank amongst the best comic creations of children's literature. Tiffany matures through the series as she struggles to become the sort of witch she wants to be, so these are wonderful books for children to grow up with, and through. They are rich in folklore and magic, but also profoundly humane, full of what you might call the milk of human kindness - as well as being some of the best entertainment around. 

The Wee Free Men is the ideal place for an 8-12 year-old to start on this enriching journey. The sequence continues with: A Hat Full of Sky, Wintersmith, I Shall Wear Midnight, and concludes with Terry Pratchett 's wonderful final book, The Shepherd's Crown 

"People think that stories are shaped by people. 
In fact, it's the other way around." Terry Pratchett, Witches Abroad


Monday, 24 April 2017

Dragon's Green by Scarlett Thomas

 

Stacked on the bookshop display, Dragon's Green was prominently stickered: THIS BOOK GLOWS IN THE DARK. For goodness sake. Decent quality fiction, even that intended for children, does not need phosphoresce to recommend it. Had I not recognised the author as one whose adult novels I have much admired (The End of Mr Y, et al), I might well have passed it by. But I did, so I didn't. I was intrigued as to whether such a writer could leave aside her literary fiction sensibilities and pen a children's book. It turned out that she couldn't leave them aside. Not entirely anyway. But it didn't matter. This is a remarkable and hugely enjoyable children's novel notwithstanding. In fact it is the better book for it. I am even reconciled to its gratuitous green glow. But I will come to that. 

Many years ago, in my Boy Scout days, a regular feature of our anual camp was a competition to see how many things we could collect and fit into a matchbox. Dragon's Green reminded me of that challenge. This novel feels as if its author has collected as many features as possible of popular children's (fantasy) fiction and tried to fit them all into one small book. There are elements here of Roal Dahl, perhaps David Walliams, J.K.Rowling, of course, Alan Garner, Susan Cooper, C.S.Lewis, thankfully, without the religion, Cornelia Funke, Shannon Hale and Joanne Harris, to pick out but a few.  There are even vague echoes of Enid Blyton ('Five go on a Magical Adventure'?), though without the darned dog. Plenty of other bits and pieces get into her matchbox too. For example video role play gets a look in, its character energy status bars 'borrowed' and seen here through magic spectacles. Nor are more traditional stories neglected. The author gaily appropriates bits from George and the Dragon, Beauty and the Beast, Orpheus, Bluebeard. And is it Goblin Market in there too?

Such an eclectic, not to say hackneyed, mix sounds like a potential train crash of a book; that or a hack-written crowd-pleaser.  And in other hands it could well have been. But Scarlett Thomas is a wonderfully skilled and imaginative author.  So it isn't. Far from it.  The originality of Dragon's Green is to be found in its unoriginality. Rather it is to be found in the way its author reinterprets these familiar elements, playfully, sometimes wickedly reimagining them in new light.  Sometimes she undermines former conventions, sometimes she exploits them for delightful humour, sometimes she respectfully reinvigorates them. But always she melds them skilfully into the most fresh and captivating of stories creating a fascinating new take on children with magical abilities. She is, here, Uncle Abanazar of fantasy, but with a trickery all of her own. 

Dragon's Green is actually a book which can be approached, and appreciated, on different levels.

Whether intentionally, or simply because she cannot leave her lively intellect at home when she writes, Scarlett Thomas has crafted a book which provides much entertainment for an adult reader. It is, in no small part, a metafiction, a book about books and reading, a children's book about children's books, a fantasy about fantasy. As well as toying with the genre, its tropes and its conventions, it is jammed full of literary allusions. Many are blatant, others more esoteric*. It is self-consciously literary in a very literal sense. Other disciplines such as science and philosophy are not ignored either, and even Schrödinger's cat gets a look in. There are what I suspect to be academic in jokes too.  ('Epiphanised'. Really.) It is altogether enormously entertaining. 

However, even though these titbits will pass many children  by (Viz: 'My name is Yorick, as in "Alas poor . . . ".' ) Dragon's Green will still provide them with a thoroughly enjoyable reading experience. It has hugely likeable characters and an exciting, engrossing plot. After all, it really does take so many of the features children love in their reading, with the possible exception of animals, and combine them quite wonderfully into a credible and compelling whole. 

Yet it is to the highly literate, well-read child (and I am delighted to say there are no small few of them about) that I think Scarlett Thomas's book will bring the greatest delight. As well as revelling in the story, they will pick up many, even if not all, of the clever references and be amused by the playfulness with genre. I am sure they will equally enjoy being led to think about what fiction is and what it means to be a reader. It is good that such readers are offered not only a great story but to begin to see glimpses of the enormous treasure house that the finest fiction has to offer. And perhaps it will direct some towards other rewarding books they may not have found for themselves, at some future point if not immediately.  For this is a thinker's book too. It explores moral as well as esthetic and logical conundrums. Despite its mega villains, its true heros, healers, et al, it avoids simplistic notions of good and evil and explores the dilemmas and ambivalences which often lie between them. It is a book for all readers but the best sort of book for the best sort of reader too. Page 211 of the current UK hardback edition provides a very pertinent insight into what it is to be a creative reader. It is a wonderful passage that I think many educators will find most valuable and many readers elucidating. (Anyone interested might also wish to delve into the archives of this blog and read my own thoughts on why reading is so important, posted back in June '14.)

Most remarkably of all , perhaps, on whatever level this book is being read, by whatever age of reader, by part way through its sheer narrative power takes over , as I suspect it may have taken over its author too. It hurtles to the end in truely compulsive, page-turning style. However, in the final pages, many possibilities are left open and, as this is labelled Worldquake Book One, it will leave all those readers eager for more 

I am delighted that Scarlett Thomas has 'epiphanised' in terms of children's magic fiction. True, there is a great deal of pulp around,where cliche is piled on cliche in both content and language.  But this is is not what writing for children is about. It does not need to be like this, and often is not. It is no more fair to judge the genre on the basis of such books than to condemn all adult fiction on the basis of the worst  airport paperbacks. Children are no more discriminating than adults - but no less either. The very best of children's fantasy is fine literature on as many levels as adult fiction, and Philip Pullman is far from its only exponent. I sincerely hope that Scarlett Thomas will continue to read the best of children's fantasy, and write it too. 

And now that I have read Dragon's Green, I am reconciled to this edition's dust jacket. I even like it. Enjoy it. The book contains so many elements of child appeal, why should it not glow in the dark too? If you look very carefully you might even detect a tinge of post-irony in its luminescence. The best place to see it is under the bedclothes, once you have turned off the torch. 



Note:
*I admit to much enjoying the smug satisfaction of identifying the Bulgakov, before being told 

Sunday, 16 April 2017

The Spiral Path by Matt Griffin

 

It is great to now have the final part of Matt Griffin's Ayla Trilogy. (See post from May '16 for reviews of earlier volumes.) For the reader in me, it has  rounded off a hugely enjoyable story sequence and, for the reviewer, it has fulfilled the earlier promise that this is a fine work of children's fiction. 

The trilogy is now confirmed as sitting within the 'classic' tradition of children's fantasy (think Alan Garner, Susan Cooper, et al) yet it is more than fresh enough and rich enough to constitute a most welcome addition to this notable canon. Like its illustrious predecessors, it draws upon both rich location and deep lore for its inspiration, but this is no retelling of folktales or mythology. Matt Griffin's throws an ancient Ireland and an archetypal lore into the crucible of his own imagination and smelts a tale that is darkly original, yet resonates with what lies deep within us all. His foil to this is a group of highly credible, contemporary kids and it is in the meeting, indeed the clash, between these two disparate elements that his story lies. 

In the previous volumes,  his quartet of young protagonists has been dragged (usually kicking and screaming) into the realm of 'old' magic. Now, however, they have returned to their own world, only to find that the magic has followed them there. This is an inspired twist which ignites the story anew and only serves to intensify the conflict between reality and legend. And this is no benign magic. There is nothing of the charming here. This magic is largely malevolent - and violent, vicious, cruel, to boot. It challenges both the protagonists' and the reader's concept of 'nature' magic, and indeed of both magic and nature themselves. This is no Narnia. The Spring which awakens mid-tale carries with it more horror than hope. Like much in the story, it is a trap; both illusion and delusion. It is powerful and powerfully disturbing. 

Like the earlier ones, this is a comparatively short book in terms of word count. But it is no 'easy reader', nor is it a book for younger children. The storytelling is intense, almost condensed, at times verging on the enigmatic. (Again echoes of Garner.) It is a multi-perspective narrative that hurls one story strand on top of another. Yet there is amazing image-building too. Matt Griffin is an illustrator as well as an author. This volume, like the others, is greatly enhanced by his own starkly powerful, disturbingly dark pictures. (I found the one of the kneeling, magic-helmed Ayla particularly devastating. ) But these are echoed in the text too, which is stamped throughout with image after image from 'classic' mythology and folklore, but so often distorted, twisted, envisioned anew. The smith, the weaver's loom, goblins, bards, they are all here. And through them all, the spiral, the Troy, often implied more than described, but always leading inexorably to the centre of the magic. But what magic? Whose magic? This book asks questions too - of Ayla and her friends, and of its readers. Where might today's kids and ancient magic meet, and what might happen if they did - or do?

And is the ending as reassuring as it seems, or are its surprising final sentences as chilling as they are exciting? 

Another triumph, Mr Griffin. Please do not stop writing as well as drawing. Children's literature will be the richer. 



Monday, 10 April 2017

Lockwood & Co: The Creeping Shadow by Jonathan Stroud

 

To my mind, Jonathan Stroud’s Bartimaeus Trilogy (starting with The Amulet of Samarkand and published between 2003 and 2005) is one of the all-time greats of children's fantasy. It combines hugely entertaining comedy with really thrilling action more successfully than almost any other sequence I can think of. Sometimes drily witty, sometimes broadly farcical, each volume is laced through with delights, yet its fantasy world is built with total credibility and much originality. The character of the cantankerous ‘djinni’, Bartimaeus, is one of the most splendid and imaginative  creations of recent children’s literature, and his relationship with rather incompetent magician’s apprentice, Nathaniel, is developed quite wonderfully. Recommended every bit as strongly is the subsequently written prequel, The Ring of Solomon (2010).

In truth, I have not felt his more recent children's/YA series, Lockwood & Co (started 20012), to be in quite the same league in terms of originality. These books involve the exploits of a small 'firm' of teenage ghostbusters, in a broadly contemporary world, which is being plagued by an extensive outbreak of the supernatural. However, each of these books is extremely well written, as I have come to expect from Jonathan Stroud, and provides great reading entertainment. They too are a clever and successful mixture of humour and viscerally exciting action, with strongly drawn, interesting and likeable characters, as well as a whole cast of gruesome spooks. Jonathan Stroud most certainly has an imagination with a strong feel for the supernatural. These are haunting adventures in every sense; entertainingly dark, whilst falling short of being seriously disturbing. 

The latest in the series, The Creeping Shadow, is the best yet. Three elements in particular ratchet up its involving readability. Lucy Carlyle, the narrator, undoubtedly talented but actually somewhat insecure, was a founder member and stalwart of Lockwood & Co. Now, however, she has left the firm to set up as an indendent investigator. Her reasons I will not reveal,  as that would be something of a spoiler. However, the hanging question of whether or not she should or will return to the fold of her old firm adds an extra frisson to the story. In fact her relationship with enigmatic Lockwood is developing (or not, as the case may be). It teeters somewhere on an intriguing cusp between teenage friendship and pre-sexual romance. Frisson upon frisson, then. 

Additionally Lucy's conversations with the gruesome talking skull, which she insists on carrying about with her, have developed something of the same entertaining love-hate relationship as Nathaniel had with Bartimaeus. Jonathan Stroud has cleverly transposed a winning formula into his new context, changed it enough to be novel, but retained its huge entertainment value. Laughs upon laughs then. 

Finally this book significantly ups the ante for our psychic investigators. Now it is no longer simply (!) the ghosts, ghouls and other grizzlies that the intrepid teens have to battle. There is a mega-villain to be thwarted, and perhaps an even bigger, badder one over the horizon. Not only horror upon horror, but thrill upon thrill too. 

This series has now developed into something very special in its own right. The next book, heralded as the final climactic one, will be eagerly anticipated by many fans - and they certainly include me. 


Saturday, 8 April 2017

The House of Mountfathom by Nigel McDowell

 

My posts from June and October '14 have already recorded my profound admiration for writer Nigel McDowell, who died at a tragically young age early last year. Thankfully, we now have his posthumously published third and  final work, The House of Mountfathom. 
 
In his three books, Nigel McDowell has pushed the boundaries of children's/YA literature in brave and remarkable ways. Because of this, his contribution to the canon is considerable. His work is lyrical, thoughtful, at times almost mystical. It is resonant of myth and magic. It is powerfully political and intensely personal. It is of the past and of the future. Yet, in the present, it is profoundly human and deeply loving.

His books are not a trilogy, although  his trademark themes interweave between them, as do his exciting adventures with both language and narrative form. This third book is again a wildly original and imaginative amalgam that mixes echos of Irish political strife and violence with the translucent shimmer of fading magic.  The land  is being overrun by hatred and conflict, and the old magical order, which has long upheld its peace, is failing to take. Protagonist, Luke, seems destined to become the last of his magical family, the titular  Mountfathom, 'house' in both its dynastic and architectural sense. 

The story of Luke's growing is a baroque fantasy where an intertwining dance of narrative and language, content and form, weaves a spell of fiction that feeds on the very highest traditions of Irish writing   It is breathtakingly done. The house itself must be one of fantasy literature's most enchanting and enchanted creations; its weird and wonderful rooms delight the imagination and thrill the senses. Opposed to it, however, is all that is violent and self-seeking, whether this is the authoritarian rule of 'the castle', or the freedom-fighting rebels and 'land-grabbers'. Worst of all is the dark magic of 'Westminster', turned to political and destructive ends. The beautiful, fey magic of Mountfathom stands little chance.

In fact this is, in many ways a bleak, ominous story. It is about death and endings. It is the fading, the forgetting of beautiful magic. Yes, it is about change of revolution The old order is certainly being overturned. The long-oppressed are asserting themselves at last. But is all for the best? I was constantly, and perhaps very appropriately, reminded of W B Yeats: 'All changed, changed utterly: A terrible beauty is born.' And, even more potently: 'Many ingenious, lovely things are gone.'

But this book is also the story of a friendship, an unexpected friendship between the magical son of the 'great house' and, Killian, a former thief from the city tenements. Have and have not. Have all and have nothing. One is proud, determined, sensitive, questioning, the other is down-to-earth and uneducated but ultimately savvy, brave and loyal. Yet they develop a mutual commitment that is rarely described, but often implied, and ultimately left beyond doubt.  Which, if either, is the  stronger is less certain. But their interdependence is the heart of the book in every sense. They hold each other's hands through the darkness 

Is The House of Mountfathom a masterpiece? It could well be.  Is it an entirely comfortable read? In truth, I think not. It is heavy going at times, rather humourless. Its unrelenting use of the present tense can be tiresome. Yet it remains a very fine piece of writing from a very fine writer; one who, I am sure , would have produced more wonderful books had he lived longer. But now we must be grateful for what we have. And indeed we are. And when, at the close, the beautiful, magical, Luke goes off into the utter, unknown dark of the 'gloaming', it is unspeakably moving. What he leaves is his friend, and love, and loss and longing - and,perhaps some hope. At the last. Luke is determined to use imagination to return the creatures of ancient magic to the land. And Killian?

I much regret that I have missed the chance to say thank you to Nigel. 'Many, ingenious, lovely things are gone.'

But the gyants and the faerie raths are back.